Join Here to Get Full Text "B. Pharmacy Projects"

Tuesday, April 21, 2009


Abdul Salam, R. Raju

National College of Pharmacy, Manassery, Calicut

Cite this: Abdul Salam, R. Raju, "Invivo screening methods of anti-inflammatory drugs – an approach to herbal drugs", B. Pharm Projects and Review Articles, Vol. 1, pp. 01-42, 2006.

    "Inflammation is the reaction of vascular supporting elements to injury and results in formation of protein rich exudates provided the injury has not been so serious as to destroy the area".25

    It is localized tissue response to injury by physical or chemical agents. It comprises a series of phenomenon occurring partly in the circulatory system and partly in the tissue in varied proportion. Inflammation is essentially beneficial; however, excess or prolonged inflammation can cause harm.26


Figure 1: Site of inflammation process
    Mechanism of inflammation is that as a result of proinflammatory cytokine and chemokine release in response to injury or infection, mast cells in connective tissue as well as basophills, neutrophills and platelets leaving the blood from injured capillaries, release or stimulates the synthesis of vasodilators such as histamine, leukotrienes, bradykinins and prostaglandins. Certain products of complement pathways (C5a and C3a) can also trigger mast cells to release their vasodialators.4, 27



Figure 2: Stage prior to vasodialation due to proinflammatory mediators
    Inflammation is the end result of complicated cascade of chemical mediators. Phospholipids are converted by enzyme phospolipase A2 to arachidonic acid (a 20 carbon unsaturated fatty acid formed in the cell membrane when required for PG synthesis). This is thus converted to endoperoxidases by COX. The endoperoxidases are the parent compound of PGD2, PGE2 and PGF2a, thromboxane-A2 and prostacyclin.2

    Prostaglandins are found in tissues throughout the body PGE2 and PGF2a seems to be associated with inflammatory reaction. Prostacyclin is synthesized in arterial walls and it increases cAMP levels in platelet preventing their activation. Thromboxane -A2 is formed in platelets where it decreases cAMP levels and leads to platelet aggregation. 25


    PG are a related family of chemicals that are produced by the cells of the body and have several important functions. They promote inflammation, pain, fever, support function of platelets that are necessary for clotting of blood and protect the lining of stomach from damaging effects of acid. Prostaglandin are produced within the body's cell by enzyme COX. There are actually 2 COX enzyme COX-1 (constitutive) and COX-2 (inducible). Both enzymes produce PG and promote inflammation, pain, and fever but mainly by COX-2. Moreover, only COX-1 produce PG that support platelets and protect the stomach and regulate renal blood flow.1, 3



    NSAIDs blocks the COX enzyme and reduce PG throughout the body. As a consequence ongoing inflammation, pain and fever are reduced. Since PG that protect stomach and support the platelet and blood clotting also are reduced, NSAIDs can cause ulcer in stomach and promote bleeding.

    They are divided into 2 classes:

NSAIDs and Corticosteroids
    NSAIDs are COX inhibitors and this inhibits the conversion of AA to unstable endoperoxidases from which often inflammatory compounds are derived. But corticosteroids act one step higher up the pathway by stimulating the synthesis of the inhibitory protein lipocortin that inhibits the enzyme phospholipase A2 from converting phospholipids to arachidonic acid. They therefore reduce the production of Leukotrienes C4 and D4, which are also involved with inflammation.24
    NSAIDs have analgesic, antipyretic and anti-inflammatory activity. Antipyretic activity is exerted by inhibiting the rise of levels of PG in the brain, which acts as pyrogens, acting directly on the thermo-regulatory centre in the hypothalamus, to increase body temperature. Their analgesic and anti inflammatory effect is due to inhibition of PG synthesis in the inflammed tissues and therefore is on a peripheral level. PG cause little pain themselves but potentiate the pain caused by other mediators with bradykinin and histamine.24

    Aspirin is oldest NSAID and is very effective. It is used at far lower doses to inhibit clotting of blood and prevent strokes and heart attacks in individuals at high risk. However, up to 50% of patients are unable to tolerate the adverse effects i.e. nausea, vomiting, epigastric pain and tinnitus that are caused by high doses necessary to achieve an anti-inflammatory effect.5


    NSAIDs vary in their potency, duration of action and way in which they are eliminated from the body, but they all have common mechanism of action. The newer NSAIDs are more selective for COX-2 and are therefore claimed to cause less GI toxicity. Therefore it is recommended that until more research is published confirming the clear, clinical benefits for using these COX-2 inhibitors that a conventional NSAID be chosen on the basis of incidence of GI and other side effects. Eg: celecoxib (celebrex), blocks COX-2, but has little effect on COX-1. This drug is referred to as one of the selective COX-2 inhibitor and cause less bleeding and fewer ulcers than other NSAIDs.24

    The drugs that the committee on safety of medicines (CSM) considers to be low risk with respect to GI side effects are ibuprofen and mefenamic acid. diclofenac, naproxen and indomethacin are considered be intermediate risk, with that of azapropazone and phenyl butazone being considered high risk.24

    If a full analgesic effect is not achieved after 1 week, and a full anti inflammatory effect after 3 week another drug should be tried. Ibuprofen is often tried first because of its good side effect profile. Other commonly used drugs are diclofenac, ketoprofen, naproxen and indomethacin.5

    The GI side effects of NSAIDs are dyspepsia, nausea, and occasionally occult blood loss and ulceration. Other side effects include hypersensitivity reaction including rashes, angioedema and bronchospasm, headache, dizziness, vertigo, tinnitus, fluid retention and rarely renal failure, hepatic damage, alveolitis, pulmonary eosinophillia and Steven-Johnson syndrome. They are recommended to avoided in those patients with asthma.5

    NSAIDs interact with many different class of drugs. The anti-hypertension effect of ACE inhibitor, angiotension-2 antagonist, beta blockers and diuretics are antagonized. Individuals with a serious allergy to one NSAID are likely to experience a similar reaction to a different NSAID. NSAID also decrease ability of blood to clot and therefore increase bleeding time. Therefore individuals who are taking drugs that reduce the ability of blood to clot should avoid prolonged use of NSAIDs.24


    Here glucocorticoid activity suppresses inflammation, allergy and immune responses. It is important to realize that to be effective as an anti-inflammatory, an agent needs to combine high glucocorticoid activity with relatively low mineral corticoid activity. Drugs with predominantly glucocorticoid activity are therefore used in many disease states where inflammation is a clinical manifestation, e.g.: asthma, inflammatory bowel disease, rheumatoid arthritis and severe inflammatory condition of hand and skin.26

    Prednisolone is most commonly used corticosteroid because of its predominantly glucocorticoid activity.

    Dexamethacone has particularly high glucocorticoid activity and low minerello corticoid activity and therefore can be used in high doses, in condition such as cerebral edema. Triamcinolone is commonly used in arthritis. In the form of an intra-articular injection to decrease local inflammation of joints.

    The use of corticosteroid for long term is limited by extensive range of side effects they can cause. Metabolic effects include Cushing's syndrome, which is manifested by development of moon face and redistribution of fat from extremities to the face and trunk. Carbohydrate metabolism is altered leading to hyperglycemia and occasionally diabetes. Skeletal muscle wasting and weakness occur secondary to protein loss. Osteoporosis results from increased bone catabolism and patients develop skin striac and they also bruise easily.26

    Patients on corticosteroids are also more susceptible to infections, due to immune system suppression. Psychosis, glaucoma, cataracts and peptic ulceration can also occur.


    Herbal plants with anti-inflammatory action:

(i) GINGER28
    It appears to relieve inflammatory pain as effectively as aspirin, ibuprofen and other NSAIDs, without their adverse side effects.

    Ginger does this by partially blocking COX-2 enzymes, which are necessary for inflammation. Unlike synthetic NSAIDs, it does not block COX-1, and therefore does not produce gastric bleeding associated with these drugs.

    Ginger therapeutic promise is supported by extensive evidence of strong anti-inflammatory effects in animals, and the very positive results of two preliminary clinical trials from Denmark.

    In the first study, seven patients were given ginger for 3 months, and each of them reported better relief from stiffness, swelling, and pain and they had experienced from synthetic NSAIDs.

    In the second study, ginger was given to patients with RA, patients with osteoarthritis and 10 patients with fibromyalgia like symptoms. In the end, three out of four experienced significant relief from pain and swelling.

    Gingerols, active constituent of ginger (rhizome of zingiber officinale) is a potential new class of platelet activation inhibitor. In a study, the ability of a series of synthetic gingerols and related phenyl alkanol analogues (G1 – G7) to inhibit human platelet activation, compared to aspirin, by measuring their effects on arachidonic acid (AA) induced platelet serotonins release and aggregation in vitro. Gingerols and related analogues (G1 - G7) inhibited the AA induced platelet release reaction in a similar dose range as aspirin, with IC50 values between 45.3 and 82.6 mM. G1 - G7 were also effective inhibitor of AA induced human platelet aggregation.

    The mechanism underlying inhibition of the AA- induced platelet release reaction and aggregation by G1-G7 may be via an effect on COX activity in platelets because representative gingerols and related analogues (G3-G6) potently inhibited COX activity in rat basophilic leukemia (RBL-2H3) cell.

    Ginger in one research study gives that 3 - 7g of ginger a day to 28 people with RA. More than 75% of those participating in study reported at least some relief from pain and swelling. Even after more than 2 years of taking these high doses of ginger, none of people reported side effects. Many drink ginger tea for arthritis.

    Curcumin, yellow pigment of turmeric has significant anti-inflammatory action. Curcumin has been shown to be as effective as cortisone or phenyl butozone in certain models of inflammation.

    Curcumin is sometimes given in combination with an equal dose of an extract of the pineapple plant called bromelain, which appears to possess anti-inflammatory properties of its own.

    Curcumin is safe; side effects are rare and are generally limited to occasional allergic reaction and mild stomach upset.

    The possible anticarcinogenic activity of curcumin and other curcuminoids may be accounted for by a few mechanisms. These include inhibition of angiogenesis, up regulation of apoptosis, interference with certain signal transduction pathways that are critical for cell growth and proliferation, inhibition of colonic mucosa cyclooxygenase (COX) and LOX activity and inhibition of farnesyl protein transference.

    The possible anti-inflammatory activity of curcuminoids may also be accounted for several mechanisms, including inhibition of COX and LOX, reduction of the release of ROS (Reaction Oxygen Species) by stimulated neutrophils, inhibition of AP-1 and NF-

Kappa B and inhibition of activation of pro-inflammatory cytokines TNF (Tumour necrosis factor) - alpha and IL (interleukin)-1 beta and interleukin-8.

(iii) BERBERIS25
    Berberine, an alkaloid has anti-inflammatory action. A study was made on COX-2 because it play a key role in PG synthesis, which is elevated in inflammation.

    In oral cancer cell line OC2 and KB cells, a 12 hour berberine treatment (1, 10, 100 mM) reduced PGE2 production dose-dependently with or without 12-0-tetradecanoyl phorbol-13-acetate (TPA, 10 nM) induction. This berberine induced effect occurred rapidly (3 h) as a result of reduced COX-2 protein, but not enzyme activity. The electrophoretic mobility shift assay revealed that activator protein 1 (AP-1) binding was decreased in oral cancer cells treated with berberine for 2h. Further analysis showed that berberine inhibited AP-1 binding directly. These anti-inflammatory effects paralleled to the in vivo results were berberine pre-treatment of wistar rat inhibited production of exudates and PGE2 in carrageenan induced air pouch.

(iv) GUGGUL30
    In guggul there is gum resin, which contains guggulsterone, a steroid compound. It appears to be effective in lowering both total cholesterol and LDL cholesterol.

    Guggulosterone has significant anti-inflammatory properties, as though they are some what overshadowed by its effects on lipid metabolism. This shows its use for treatment of Rheumatoid arthritis and other inflammatory condition. Studies have also shown guggulsterone to be at least as effective as conventional medication phenylbutazone and ibuprofen (Advil, Motrin) for both acute and chronic types of inflammation in animal models.

    It has also shown that Guggulosterone have approximately the same effectiveness as the antibiotic tetracycline for the treatment of nodulocystic acne. It decreases inflammation and lower the risk of recurrence of condition.



(v) ALOE (Aloe vera) 29
    Best for minor wounds. It helps minimizing wound swelling, antimuscular and immune-stimulating action that help prevent wound infection.

    From licorice roots, inhibits inflammatory process of all sorts, including hepatitis and allergies, all of which produce destructive oxidants in the blood.

Other drugs with anti-inflammatory actions are29,
  1. Agrimony (Agrimonia eupatoria)
  2. Butcher's broom (Ruscus A\aculeatus)
  3. Chamomile
  4. Chicory (Cichorium intybus)
  5. Fever few (Chrysanthemum parthenium)
  6. Marigold (Calendula officinalis)
  7. St. John's wort (Hypericum perforatum)
  8. Wild yam (Dioscorea villosa)



Various in vivo screening methods were done in animals. Those are:

1) PAW EDEMA13, 14, 15
Purpose and Rationale
Among the many methods used for screening of anti-inflammatory drugs, one of the most commonly employed techniques is based upon the ability of such agents to inhibit the edema produced in the hind paw of the rat after injection of a phlogistic agent. Many phlogistic agents (irritants) have been used, such as brewer's yeast, formaldehyde, dextran, egg albumin, kaolin, Aerosil, sulfated polysaccharides like carrageenin or naphthoylheparamine. The effect can be measured in several ways. The hind limb can be dissected at the talocrural joint and weighed. Usually, the volume of the injected paw is measured before and after application of the irritant and the paw volume of the treated animals is compared to the controls. Many methods have been described how to measure the paw volume by simple and less accurate and by more sophisticated electronically devised methods. The value of the assessment is less dependent on the apparatus but much more on the irritant being chosen. Some irritants induce only a short lasting inflammation whereas other irritants cause the paw edema to continue over more than
24 hr.


Male or female Sprague-Dawley rats with a body weight between 100 and 150 g are used. The animals are starved overnight. To insure uniform hydration, the rats receive 5 ml of water by stomach tube (controls) or the test drug dissolved or suspended in the same volume. Thirty minutes later, the rats are challenged by a subcutaneous injection of 0.05 ml of 1% solution of carrageenan into the plantar side of the left hind paw. The paw is marked with ink at the level of the lateral malleolus and immersed in mercury up to this mark. The paw volume is measured plethysmographically immediately after injection, again 3 and 6 h, and eventually 24 h after challenge.




The increase of paw volume after 3 or 6 h is calculated as percentage compared with the volume measured immediately after injection of the irritant for each animal. Effectively treated animals show much less edema. The difference of average values between treated animals and control groups is calculated for each time interval and statistically evaluated. The differences at the various time intervals give some hints for the duration of the anti-inflammatory effect. A dose- response curve is run for active drugs and ED50 values can be determined.

Many agents can be used as irritants to induce paw edema in rats or mice. These are:
0.1 ml of 1% ovalbumin solution (Turner 1965)
0.1 ml of 1% formalin (Turner 1965)
0.1 ml of 0.2% carrageenan solution (Schönhöfer 1967)
0.1 ml of 1% carrageenan solution plus
100 ng PGE2 or PGI2 (Higgs et al. 1978; Portanova et al. 1996)
0.1 ml of 1 to 3% dextran solution (Turner 1965)
0.1 ml of 2.5% brewer's yeast powder suspension (Tsumuri et al. 1986)
0.1 ml of 0.1% trypsin solution (Kalbhen and Smalla 1977)
0.1 ml of solution of 100 IU hyaluronidase (Dewes 1955, Kalbhen and Smalla 1977)
0.05 ml of 0.02% serotonin solution (Kalbhen and Smalla 1977)
0.1 ml of 0.1 mg/ml prostaglandin E2 (Nikolov et al. 1978)
0.01 ml of 0.5% adriamycin (mouse paw) (Siegel et al. 1980)
0.1 ml of 2.5% mustard powder suspension (Tsumuri et al. 1986)
0.1 ml of 0.25% suspension of papaya latex (Gupta et al. 1994)

    The edema induced by the various irritants lasts for different times such as a few hours after serotonin and up to 2 days after Aerosil or after kaolin. These irritants therefore are suitable to study not only the degree but also the duration of the anti-inflammatory action.

Depending on the irritant steroidal and nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs have a pronounced effect in the paw edema test. With carrageenan as irritant doses of 50 to 100 mg/kg phenylbutazone p.o. have been found to be effective.

Critical Assessment of the Method
The paw edema method has been used by many investigators and has been proven to be suitable for screening purposes as well as for more in depth evaluations. Dependent on the irritant steroidal and nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, antihistaminics and also, to a lesser degree, serotonin antagonists are active in the paw edema tests.


    Besides paw volume Shirota et al. (1984) determined the surface temperature of the inflamed paw in rats using a special cage with rolling rods. Brooks et al. (1991) used anesthetized dogs and demonstrated that a significant inflammatory response can be elicited in the dog paw by subcutaneous injection of carrageenan. The increase in paw volume can be quantitatively measured as a pressure change recorded via a water-filled balloon fixed against the paw with nonexpandable tape. Effective doses of non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs were closer to human therapeutic doses in dogs than in rats.


    Wirth et al. (1992) described a thermic edema which was induced in anesthetized Sprague-Dawley rats by immersing paws of the right and left hind limb into water of 55 °C. Immediately thereafter, the rats received the test drug (the bradykinin antagonist Hoe 140) intravenously. Paw volume was measured at regular intervals by plethysmography. Braga da Motta et al. (1994) described drug modulation of antigen-induced paw edema in guinea-pigs. Male short-haired guinea pigs weighing 250–350 g received on day 0 a single dorsal s.c. injection of 1 ml of phosphate buffered saline containing 20 mg of ovalbumin, dispersed in 1 mg Al(OH)3. The animals were boosted with a similar injection of antigen on days 14, 21, and 28. Thirty five days after the first injection of antigen or Al(OH)3, the animals received an intraplantar injection of 0.5, 5, 50, or 200 mg ovalbumin, diluted in 100 ml of phosphate buffered saline. Edema was measured 2, 4, 6, 8, 24, and 48 h after the challenge.

Purpose and Rationale
    The method has been developed primarily as a bioassay for the concomitant assessment of the antiphlogistic and thymolytic activities of topically applied steroids by Tonelli et al. (1965).

    For tests in mice the irritant is composed as follows (v/v): 1 part Croton oil, 10 parts ethanol, 20 parts pyridine, 69 parts ethyl ether. For tests in rats the following mixture is prepared (v/v): 4 parts Croton oil, 10 parts ethanol, 20 parts pyridine, 66 parts ethyl ether. The standards and the test compounds are dissolved in this solution. For tests in mice male NMRI-mice with an weight of 22 g, for tests in rats male Sprague-Dawley rats with a weight of 70 g are used. Ten animals are used for controls and each test group. The test compounds are dissolved in a concentration of 0.03 mg/ml to 1 mg/ml for mice and in a 3 to 10 time's higher concentration for rats in the irritant solution. On both sides of the right ear 0.01 ml in mice or 0.02 ml in rats are applied. Controls receive only the irritant solvent. The left ear remains untreated. The irritant is applied under ether anaesthesia. Four hours after application the animals are sacrificed under anaesthesia. Both ears are removed and discs of 8 mm diameter are punched. The discs are weighed immediately and the weight difference between the treated and untreated ear is recorded indicating the degree of inflammatory edema. In the originally described method the ears are removed by sharp, straight scissors 6 h after application and weighed as total. The animals were sacrificed 48 h after topical ad-ministration and the thymus glands were removed, weighed and expressed as mg thymus/100 g body weight.


    The antiphlogistic effect can be determined by expressing the increase in weight of the treated ear as percentage of the weight of the contra lateral control ear. The difference of both weights is divided by the weight of the contra lateral ear times 100. Otherwise, the difference between either ears or excised discs is calculated as the average values for treated and control groups and the effect is evaluated by statistical methods. Concentration of 0.5 to 1 mg/ml hydrocortisone has been proven to be effective.


Critical Assessment of the Method
    The method is useful for evaluation of anti-inflammatory topical steroids especially in the modification when thymus weight is determined simultaneously. The method also can be used for topically applied nonsteroidal antiphlogistics.

Purpose and Rationale
    The oxazolone-induced ear edema model as first described by Evans (1971) in mice is a model of delayed contact hypersensitivity that permits the quantitative evaluation of the topical and systemic anti-inflammatory activity of a compound following topical administration.

    Mice of either sex with a weight of 25 g are used. Before each use a fresh 2% solution of oxazolone (4-ethoxymethylene-2-phenyl-2-oxazolin-5-one) in acetone is prepared. The mice are sensitized by application of 0.1 ml on the shaved abdominal skin or 0.01 ml on the inside of both ears under halothane anaesthesia. The mice are challenged 8 days later again under anaesthesia by applying 0.01 ml 2% oxazolone solution to the inside of the right ear (control) or 0.01 ml of oxazolone solution, in which the test compound or the standard is solved. Special pipettes of 0.1 ml or 0.01 ml are used. Groups of 10 to 15 animals are treated with the irritant alone or with the solution of the test compound. The left ear remains untreated. The maximum of inflammation occurs 24 h later. At this time the animals are sacrificed under anaesthesia and a disc of 8 mm diameter is punched from both sides. The discs are immediately weighed on a balance. The weight difference is an indicator of the inflammatory edema.




    Average values of the increase of weight are calculated for each treated group and compared statistically with the control group. A 0.003% solution of hydrocortisone and a 1% solution of indomethacin were found to be active.

Critical Assessment of the Method
    The method is suitable for both steroidal and non-steroidal compounds as well as for the evaluation of various topical formulations


Purpose and Rationale
    The method originally invented by Selye has been developed for screening by Robert and Nezamis (1957) using croton oil as irritant. An aseptic inflammation resulting in large volumes of haemorrhage exudates is elicited which resembles the sub acute type of inflammation. Instead of croton oil carrageenan can be used as irritant.

    Male or female Sprague-Dawley rats with a body weight between 150 and 200 g are used. Ten animals are taken for controls and for test groups. The back of the animals is shaved and disinfected. With a very thin needle a pneumoderma is made in the middle of the dorsal skin by injection of 20 ml of air under ether anaesthesia. Into the resulting oval air pouch 0.5 ml of a 1% solution of Croton oil in sesame oil is injected avoiding any leakage of air. Forty-eight hours later the air is withdrawn from the pouch and 72 h later any resulting adhesions are broken. Instead of croton oil 1 ml of a 20% suspension of carrageenan in sesame oil can be used as irritant. Starting with the formation of the pouch, the animals are treated every day either orally or subcutaneously with the test compound or the standard. For testing local activity, the test compound is injected directly into the air sac at the same time as the irritant. On the 4th or the 5th day the animals are sacrificed under anaesthesia. The pouch is opened and the exudates are collected in glass cylinders. Controls have an exudates volume between 6 and 12 ml, which is reduced dose dependent in the treated animals.

    The average value of the exudates of the controls and the test groups is calculated. Comparison is made by statistical means. A clear dose response curve could be found by s.c. injection of 0.5, 1.0 and 2.0 mg hydrocortisone acetate/rat. Also doses of 1.5 mg/kg indomethacin were found to be active.

Critical Assessment of the Method
    The method has been very useful to estimate the potency of anti-inflammatory corticosteroids both after local and after systemic application. By injection of a depot- preparation and induction of the granuloma pouch after various time intervals up to 4 weeks the duration of action can also be determined (Vogel 1963, 1965).


Purpose and Rationale
The method has been described first by Meier et al. (1950) who showed that foreign body granulomas were provoked in rats by subcutaneous implantation of pellets of compressed cotton. After several days, histologically giant cells and undifferentiated connective tissue can be observed besides the fluid infiltration. The amount of newly formed connective tissue can be measured by weighing the dried pellets after removal. More intensive granuloma formation has been observed if the cotton pellets have been impregnated with carrageenin.

Male Wistar rats with an average weight of 200 g are anaesthetized with ether. The back skin is shaved and disinfected with 70% ethanol. An incision is made in the lumbar region. By a blunted forceps subcutaneous tunnels are formed and a sterilized cotton pellet is placed on both sides in the scapular region. The pellets are either standardized for use in dentistry weighing 20 mg or pellets formed from raw cotton which produce a more pronounced inflammation than bleached cotton. The animals are treated for 7 days subcutaneously or orally. Than, the animals are sacrificed, the pellets prepared and dried until the weight remains constant. The net dry weight, i.e. after subtracting the weight of the cotton pellet is determined.

The average weight of the pellets of the control group as well as of the test group is calculated. The percent change of granuloma weight relative to vehicle control
group is determined.

Critical Assessment of the Method
    The method has been useful for evaluation of steroidal and nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs. For testing corticosteroids, the test can be performed in adrenalectomized rats.

Purpose and Rationale
    The glass rod granuloma as first described by Vogel (1970) reflects the chronic proliferative inflammation. Of the newly formed connective tissue not only wet and dry weight, but also chemical composition and mechanical properties can be measured.

    Glass rods with a diameter of 6 mm are cut to a length of 40 mm and the ends rounded off by flame melting. They are sterilized before implantation by boiling in water. Male Sprague-Dawley rats with an initial weight of 130 g are anaesthetized with ether, the back skin shaved and disinfected. From an incision in the caudal region a subcutaneous tunnel is formed in cranial direction with a closed blunted forceps. One glass rod is introduced into this tunnel finally lying on the back of the animal. The incision wound is closed by sutures. The animals are kept in separate cages. The rods remain in situ for 20 or 40 days. Treatment with drugs is either during the whole period or only during the last 10 or 2 days. At the end the animals are sacrificed under CO2 anaesthesia. The glass rods are prepared together with the surrounding connective tissue which forms a tube around the glass rod. By incision at one end the glass rod is extracted and the granuloma sac inverted forming a plain piece of pure connective tissue. Wet weight of the granuloma tissue is recorded. The specimens are kept in a humid chamber until further analysis. For measurement of the mechanical properties the specimens are fixed into the clamps of the Instron(R) instrument allowing a gauge length of 30 mm. The load until break is recorded with a crosshead speed of 50 mm/min. In order to calculate tensile strength (N/mm2), the value of load at rupture (N) is divided by cross sectional area (measured as volume = wet weight divided by length). Finally, the granuloma tissue is dried and the dry weight is recorded. In addition, biochemical analyses, such as determination of collagen and glycosaminoglycans, can be performed.

    Several parameters can be determined by this method. Granuloma weight was reduced by corticosteroids depending on dose and time of administration and was also diminished after treatment with nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory agents and lathyrogenic compounds. Furthermore, antiproliferative terpenoids reduced the granuloma weight. The mechanical parameters showed different results after these drugs indicating a different mode of action. Treatment with corticosteroids increased tensile strength. Only after long term treatment with toxic doses a decrease was found. Anti-inflammatory compounds, such as acetylsalicylic acid or indomethacin and antiproliferative terpenoids showed an increase of strength at medium and high doses.

Critical Assessment of the Method
    In contrast to most other granuloma methods, the glass rod granuloma measures the late proliferative phase of inflammation. Since the newly formed connective tissue is not contaminated with the irritant biochemical analyses can be performed. The peculiar feature is the possibility to study the mechanical properties of newly formed proliferative connective tissue.


Purpose and Rationale
    Pleurisy is a well known phenomenon of exudative inflammation in man. In experimental animals pleurisy can be induced by several irritants, such as histamine, bradykinin, prostaglandins, mast cell degranulators, dextran, enzymes, antigens, microbes, and non-specific irritants, like turpentine and carrageenan (Survey by DeBrito 1989). Carrageenan-induced pleurisy in rats is considered to be an excellent acute inflammatory model in which fluid extravasation, leukocyte migration and the various biochemical parameters involved in the inflammatory response can be measured easily in the exudates.

    Male Sprague-Dawley rats weighing 220–260 g are used. The animal is lightly anaesthetized with ether, placed on its back and the hair from skin over the ribs of the right side is removed using animal clippers. The region is swabbed with alcohol. A small incision is made into the skin under the right arm between the seventh and eighth rib. The wound is opened and a further shallow incision is made into the exposed intercoastals muscle. 0.1 ml of 2% carrageenin solution is injected into the pleural cavity through this incision. The injection needs to be made swiftly to avoid the risk of injuring the lung. The wound is closed with a Michel clip. One hour before carrageenan injection and 24 and 48 h thereafter, groups of 10 rats are treated with the standard or the test compound subcutaneously or orally. A control group receives only the vehicle of medication. The animals are sacrificed 72 h after carrageenin injection by ether inhalation. The animal is pinned on a dissection board with the forelimbs fully extended. An incision in the skin over the xiphisternal cartilage is made to free the cartilage from overlying connective tissue. The cartilage is lifted with a forceps and a small cut is made with scissors in the body wall below to gain access into the pleural cavity. One ml of heparinized Hank's solution is injected into the pleural cavity through this cut. The cavity is gently massaged to mix its contents. The fluid is aspirated out of the cavity using a pipette. This is made easier if the dissection board is raised to an angle of 45–60°; the contents then pool in the corners of the cavity. The aspirated exudates are collected in a graduated plastic tube.

One ml (the added Hank's solution) is subtracted from the measured volume. The values of each experimental group are averaged and compared with the control group. ED50 values can be calculated using various doses. Several other parameters can be used:
  • Measuring the white blood cell number in the exudates using a Coulter counter or a hematocytometer
  • Determination of lysosomal enzyme activities
  • Determination of fibronectin
  • Determination of PGE2

Critical Assessment of the Method
    The pleurisy model has been accepted as a reliable method to study acute and sub acute inflammation allowing the determination of several parameters simultaneously or successively. The activity of steroids as well as of non-steroidal drugs can be measured (Tomlinson et al. 1994; Harada et al. 1996).

Purpose and Rationale
    The importance of urate in gout and the deposition of sodium urate in gouty tophi is well known. Faires and McCarty (1962) reported that they themselves were the subjects for a study injecting 20 mg sodium urate crystal suspension in their own knee-joint. They experienced severe pain and prostration which resembled an acute gouty attack. Based on this experience they developed an experimental model in dogs for testing anti-inflammatory compounds (McCarty et al. 1963, 1966).

    Preparations of sodium urate crystals 0.4g (0.01 Mol) sodium hydroxide pellets are dissolved in 400 ml distilled water in a glass beaker; 1.68 g (0.01 Mol) uric acid is added. The resultant opaque preparation is allowed to remain overnight at room temperature. The next morning, the crystals are harvested by decanting the supernatant solution and are then washed 3 times in cold saline, resuspended in saline and sterilized in an autoclave. Suspensions for injections are kept in rubber-stoppered, multi-dose vials containing 15 to 24 mg of urate per ml. Unanesthetized healthy dogs weighing between 18 and 25 kg are used. They are trained to lie quietly on their backs in a dog cradle under light restraint. The skin above one knee is shaved, disinfected and a sterile 21-gauge needle inserted into the joint. Slight aspiration produces a small amount of clear, viscous synovial fluid, indicating entry into the joint. The needle is left in place, a syringe containing the urate suspension is attached and volumes from 0.1 to 0.5 ml are injected into the joint (approximately 2–10 mg urate). One hour before the injection of urate crystals the animals are treated with the test compound or the standard. Experiments are designed so that a pair of dogs is tested on each of 2 days. On the first day, only one dog receives the drug. One week later the opposite knee of each dog is injected, but the other dog is treated.

    A scoring system is adopted in which inflammatory symptoms ranging from tenderness, limping, occasional 3-legged gait to complete 3-legged gait are scored from 1+ to 4+.

Critical Assessment of the Method
    In spite of the fact that the experiment originally has been performed in human volunteers and that the method closely resembles pathological conditions in man, due to animal protection law conditions the method can be recommended only for special investigations.

Purpose and Rationale
    The sponge implantation technique was described first by Saxena (1960) for short term experiments but was used subsequently to study the formation of granuloma using long-term implantation.

    Sponges used for implantation are prepared from polyvinyl foam sheets (thickness 5 mm). Discs are punched out to a standard size and weight (10.0 ±0.02 mg) using a 13 mm cork borer. The sponges are then soaked in 70% v/v ethanol for 30 min, rinsed four times with distilled water and heated at 80 °C for 2 h. Prior to implantation in the animal, the sponges are soaked in sterile 0.9% saline in which either drugs, antigens or irritants have been suspended. Typical examples include 1% carrageenan, 1% yeast, 1% Zymosan A, 6% dextran, heat killed Bordetella pertussis (4109 to 51010 organisms/ml) or 0.5% heat killed mycobacterium tuberculosis. Sponges are implanted in female Wistar rats weighing 150–200 g under ether anaesthesia. A 20 mm dorsal incision is made and the dermis separated from the underlying muscle layer by insertion of blunt forceps to form separate cavities into which sponges are inserted. Up to 8 sponges may be implanted per rat. The dorsal incision is closed with Michel clips and the animals are maintained at a constant temperature of 24 °C. For short term experiments, the animals are treated with test drug or standard once before implantation orally or subcutaneously. For long term experiments, the rats are treated daily up to 3 weeks.

    For estimation of the fluid phase of sponge exudates, e.g. protein content, enzyme levels and biological mediators such as prostaglandins as well as for leukocyte migration, the sponges are removed already after 9 h. For studying the chronic phase of inflammation besides dry weight DNA, indicating cell content, hexosamine, indicating glycosaminoglycane content, and hydroxyproline, indicating collagen content, can be determined.

Critical Assessment of the Method
    The sponge implantation technique has been proven to be a versatile method which was used and modified by many investigators.



    Ficus hispida Linn (F:Moraceae) is a moderato sized tree found throughout the outer Himalayas from Chenab eastwards to West Bengal, central and south India as well as Andaman islands in damp localities and flowers and fruits practically throughout the year. All parts of the plant have been used but the leaves are of particular interest from a medicinal point of view as an antidarrhoeal, hepatoprotective, antitussive, antipyretic, astringent, anti-inflammatory, haemostatic and anti-ulcer among other.8

    The leaves of Ficus hispida were collected from Varanasi, (U.P). The leaves were collected and dried under shade, pulverized in a mechanical grinder and stored in a closed container for further use. The powdered leaves were extracted with petroleum ether (60-80o) which was discarded and then again extracted with methanol in a Soxhlet apparatus. On evaporation of methanol from the methanol extract in vacuo a greenish colored residue was obtained with respect to the dry starting material and was stored in a desicator. On preliminary phytochemical screening the methanol extract showed positive test for saponins, tannins, glycosides and alkaloids.9

Edema represents the early phase of inflammation in carraggeenan-induced paw edema and is the simplest and most widely used model for studying the anti-inflammatory activity of new compounds. Rats were divided into three groups of six animals each. The first group served as the control and received vehicle only (1% Tween 80 solution in distilled water). Second group of animals were administered with standard drug diclofenac sodium (150 mg/kg, orally). Third group was treated with methanol extract (400 mg/kg, orally). The dose of extracts was selected on the basis of acute toxicity test. A mark was made on both the hind paws just below the tibio-tarsal junction so that every time the paw could be dipped in the mercury column of plythysmograph up to the mark to ensure constant paw volume. Thirty minutes after treatment, an inflammatory edema was induced in the left hind paw by injection of 0.1 ml of carrageenan (1% w/v) in the plane tissue of the paw of all the animals. The right paw served as a reference to non-inflammed paw for comparison. The relative increase in the paw volume was measured in control, standard and sample treated groups in the time duration of 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 hr. after carrageenan injection. The degree of edema formation was assayed by the percentage increase in paw volume i.e., edema rate (E) in animals treated with standard drug and the treated with extracts of Ficus hispida leaves. These were compared with the increased paw volume of control animals. Thus, percent inhibition of paw volume in treated animals ie., edema rate (E)% = (Vt/Vc) ´ 100 which was used for calculating the percent inhibition of edema using the formula:
Inhibition rte (l) % = [1 – (Vt/Vc)] ´ 100,
where Vt and Vc are the mean relative changes in the paw volume of the test and control respectively.10,11

Table 1
Anti-inflammatory Activity of Extracts of Ficus hispida Leaves in Carrageenan induced Rat Hind Paw edema Model
Dose (mg/kg, p.o)
Paw volume mean ± SE
% inhibition of edema 
0 hr
1 hr 
2 hr
3 hr
4 hr
Standard (diclofenac sodium)
Methanol extract 
ap<0.001, bp<0.01 when compared with the control values of corresponding hour; n = 6.

    The experimental results were expressed as the mean ±
standard error of mean (SEM) and the statistical significance was evaluated by using the Student's t-test. The p-values of less than 0.001 imply significance.

    Table - 1 clearly indicates that the methanol extract of Ficus hispida leaves showed maximal anti-inflammatory effect in the carrageenan induced rat paw edema. In carrageenan hind paw edema test, statistically it was found that there was no reduction in the edema in all the groups with test drug after 1 hr. but at the end of 4 hr, methanol extract 400 mg/kg p.o., significantly reduced the paw volume, which is comparable to control group. After 4 hr. the methanol extract, reduced inflammation by around 64.07%,
whereas standard drug diclofenac sodium (150 mg/kg p.o. reduced the inflammation by around 45.13%).6

Example 27
    Calamus rotang Linn (F: Palmae) is a shrub, distributed endemically in India. Rhizomes are astringent, acrid and bitter in taste. They are used as expectorant, anti-inflammatory, diuretic, febrifuge and as tonic. This plant has been traditionally used for reducing inflammation; hence, 95% ethanol extract of C. rotang was evaluated for anti-inflammatory activity in different phases of inflammation in animal models.

    Rhizomes were collected from Coutrallam, Tamilnadu and authenticity was confirmed with local Floras. They were shade dried, cut into small pieces and powdered in a pulverizer. Coarse powder was extracted with ethanol using Soxhlet apparatus. CRE was suspended in 0.75% carboxy methyl cellulose and used throughout the experiment. They were analysed for anti-inflammatory activity by carrageenan induced paw edema and cotton pellet granduloma models. Male Wistar rats weighing between 150 and 200 g procured from King Institute, Guindy, Chennai were selected for the studies.7

    For carrageenan-induced paw edema model, rats were grouped into 7 groups, containing 6 animals per group. Group 1 served as negative control. The second group served as positive control (phenylbutazone 5 mg/kg), while the other groups received CRE in different doses of 50, 100, 150, 200 and 250mg/kg orally.

    In cotton pellet granuloma model, rats were divided into 7 groups, containing 6 animals per group. Group 1 served as negative control (1 ml of Saline). The second group served as positive control and received phenylbutazone 5 mg/kg. While the other groups received CRE (50, 100, 150, 200 and 250 mg/kg orally). After shaving off the fur on the dorsal side, rats wre anaesthetized with pentobarbitone (30 mg/kg), through a single middle incision on the dorsal surface, sterilized pre-weighed cotton pellets (50 ± 1 mg) were implanted in both axillae and groins according to standard methods. Extracts were administered orally, daily for 10 days (0 to 9 days). On the 10th day, the animals were sacrificed and cotton pellets were dissected out, dried at 600 and weighed.

Table 2
Effect of calamus rotang on carrageenan-induced paw edema

Dose (mg/kg, orally) 
Edema volume (ml)
Inhibition (%) 
Control phenylbutazone
C rotang
C rotang
C rotang
C rotang
C rotang 
Saline 1.0ml
0.87 ± 0.04
0.41 ± 0.05
0.68 ± 0.03
0.60 ± 0.05
0..47 ± 0.02
0.40 ± 0.02
0.44 ± 0.04

    Table 2 illustrates the effects of CRE in carrageenan induced edema. Edema suppressant effect of 150, 200 and 250 mg/kg doses were 46.0, 54.0 and 49.4% respectively. Table 2 demonstrates the effect at the dose level on 200 and 250 mg/kg, which inhibited granuloma formation showing a dose dependent inhibitory effect on the granuloma weight.
Table 3
Effect of Calamus rotang on granulation weight
Dose (mg/kg orally) 
Edema volume (ml) 
Inhibition %
Control Saline 1.0 ml 79.17 ± 3.64
52.86 ± 12.3333.23 
C. rotang 
66.15 ± 3.5616.45 
C. rotang 
60.73 ± 1.5523.29 
C. rotang 
59.48 ± 1.1224.87 
C. rotang 
57.40 ± 2.2627.50 
C. rotang 
57.46 ± 0.7527.42

    Carrageenan-induced paw edema was taken as prototype of exudative phase of inflammation, where development of edema being described as biphasic. The initial phase is attributable to release of histamine, serotonin and kinins in the first hour after
injection of carrageenan. A more pronounced second phase is related to the release of prostaglandins like substances in 2 to 3 h.29

    In cotton pellet granuloma model, inflammation and granuloma develops during the period of several days. This model is an indication of the proliferative phases of inflammation. Inflammation involved proliferation of macrophages, neutrophils and fibroblasts, which are basic sources for granuloma formation. Therefore the decrease in granuloma weight indicates suppression of the proliferative phases, which was effectively inhibited by CRE in the present study. The anti-inflammatory activity of CRE at a dose of 200 mg is also comparable with the standard drug phenylbutazone.


    It was estimated from the above methods that paw edema method is the conventional method followed by research workers because it is simplest of other methods and with this method the acute phase of inflammation can easily be assessed thus the treatment evaluation can also be made. Other methods are also used to find the chronic phase of inflammation like cotton pellet granuloma method.
Accordingly the carrageenan test was selected in the two evaluation tests taken (of herbal extracts) because of its sensitivity in detecting orally active anti-inflammatory agents, particularly, in acute phase of inflammation . It has also been understood that extracts of herbal drugs (Ficus hispida & Calamus rotang) are most effective than those of non-steroidal drugs in reducing inflammation, also the side effect profile of synthetic drugs can be reduced . The clinical application of these findings must await further studies, though the studies are in progress to identify the active ingredients in these plant extracts responsible for anti-inflammatory activity. So these findings will be a boon to our present world.

  1. Betram.G. Katzung , editor. "Lange- Basic & Clinical Pharmacology." International ed. 9th .Prentice hall .internationals ;p no:298-309
  2. Kumar, Coutram, Robbins, editors. "Robbin¢s –Basic Pharmacology". 7th ed. Saunders ,an imprint of Elsevier Science, the curtis center ,independence squire wart Philadelphia, pensylvania 19106
  3. Harsh Mohan, editor. "Textbook of Pathology". 5th Ed. Jaypee Brothers Medical publishers (P)LTD New Delhi ; pg no :145
  4. S.G.Deodhare."General Pathology &Pathology of Systems". 6th Ed. Popular prakashan Mumbai ; pg no:335,360
  5. R.S. Satoshkar, S.D. Bhandarkar, S.S. Ainapure,"Pharmacology & Pharmacotherapeutics" . 18th Ed. Popular Prakashan, Mumbai ;pg no:156,158
  6. Indian journal of Natural products 209(3), 27 "Evaluation of anti-inflammatory activity of leaf extract of Ficus hispida".
  7. Indian journal of pharmaceutical sciences (July- august 2005) "Anti-inflammatory activity of Calamus rotang " ; Pg no: 499,500
  8. Nadkarni .AK "Indian Materia Medica" vol I Popular Prakashan, Bombay 1976 ;pg no: 1031
  9. Kokate. C.K "Practical Pharmacognosy 2nd edition Vallabh Prakashan, New Delhi 1988 ;pg no: 119
  10. Winter .C.A, Rusley E .A. , Nuss .C.W Experimental Biology & Medicine 1962 111 ; pg no: 544-547
  11. Turner .R.A "Screening Methods in Pharmacology" Academic Press Inc,London 1965 ; pg no : 152
  12. Vogel G .In ; "Drug Discovery & Evaluation" Springer-verlag, New York 2002 ;pg no: 725
  13. Alpermann HG, Magerkurth KO (1972) Messanordnung zur Bestimmung der Wirkung von Antiphlogistika. Arzneim Forsch/Drug Res 22: 1078–1088
  14. Brooks RR, Carpenter JF, Jones SM, Ziegler TC, Pong SF (1991) Canine carrageenin-induced acute paw inflammation model and its response to nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs. J Pharmacol Meth 25: 275–283
  15. Gupta OP, Sharma N, Chand D (1994) Application of papaya latex-induced rat paw inflammation: model for evaluation of slowly acting antiarthritic drugs. J Pharmacol Toxicol Meth 31: 95–98
  16. Akiyama H, Kanzaki H, Abe Y, Tada H, Arata J (1994)Staphylococcus aureus infection on experimental croton oil-inflamed skin in mice. J Dermatol Sci 8:1–10
  17. Griswold DE, DiLorenzo JA, Calabresi P (1974) Quantification and pharmacological dissection of oxazolone-induced contact sensitivity in the mouse. Cell Immunol 11: 198–204. [Cross Reference]
  18. Vogel HG (1977) Mechanical and chemical properties of connective tissue organs in rats as influenced by non-steroidal antirheumatic drugs. Conn Tiss Res 5:91–95. [Cross Reference]
  19. Hicks R (1969) The evaluation of inflammation induced by material implanted subcutaneously in the rat. J Pharm Pharmacol, 21:581–588. [Cross Reference]
  20. Ackerman N, Tomolonis A, Miram L, Kheifets J, Martinez S, Carter A (1980) Three day pleural inflammation: A new model to detect drug effects on macrophage accumulation. J Pharmacol Exp Ther 215: 588–595. [Cross Reference]
  21. Botrel MA, Haak T, Legrand C, Concordet D, Chevalier R, Toutain PL (1994) Quantitative evaluation of an experimental inflammation induced with Freund's complete adjuvant in dogs. J Pharmacol Toxicol Meth 32: 63–71. [Cross Reference]
  22. Higgs GA (1989) Use of implanted sponges to study the acute inflammatory response. In: Pharmacological Methods in the Control of Inflammation. Alan R. Liss, Inc., pp 151–171.
  23. Atkinson RM, Jenkins L, Tomich EG, Woollett EA (1962) The effects of some anti-inflammatory substances on carrageenin induced granulomata. J Endocrinol 25: 87–93. [Cross Reference]
  24. http// www.medicine
  25. http// www.Tulane medical pathology
  26. http// www.microbiology lecture guide unit 2 III E inflammation
  27. http// www.cherokee valley .com/herbs.html
  28. Http// www.

Cite this: Abdul Salam, R. Raju, "Invivo screening methods of anti-inflammatory drugs – an approach to herbal drugs", B. Pharm Projects and Review Articles, Vol. 1, pp. 01-42, 2006. (


Bela Natasha said...

It is no longer news that the Acquired immune deficiency syndrome /Human Immune Virus (HIV/AIDS) is increasing by the day. The fear is that many people living with the sickness are scared of saying it because of the stigma that comes along with it.I am bold enough among many others to state that there is now a potent cure to this sickness but many are unaware of it. I discovered that I was infected with the virus 3 months ago, after a medical check-up. My doctor told me and I was shocked, confused and felt like my world has crumbled. I was dying slowly due the announcement of my medical practitioner but he assured me that I could lead a normal life if I took my medications (as there was no medically known cure to HIV). I went from churches to churches but soon found that my case needed urgent attention which i got from a herbal man Dr. Magana, this man is a native doctor who cure different kind of sickness you can receive a package from him anywhere you are in the world please contact him on this email:, contact if you have similar problems

Vashikaran Prediction said...

Thanks for the magic problem solution

Pamela Parker said...

Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) block the COX enzymes and reduce prostaglandins throughout the body.Safe from Medications that can cause Damage of
your body parts..Kratom Withdrawal

Myerlee pharmacy said...

Dear admin.
Very useful information about pharmacy services.
Thank you for your post.
fort myers pharmacy

Pamela Parker said...

no discipline, too much money, too much power to the youth, no humility, too much pride and no moral constraint trends drug addiction among youth or teen age people.
It's a severe problem in this era.Drug rehab Indianapolis